Connect with us

BUSINESS

Court Dismisses Compensation Suit Of Man Who Allegedly Suffered Disability While Working In Seven-Up

Published

on

The National Industrial Court, has dismissed a compensation suit for alleged permanent disability brought before it by one Shedrach Daniel against Seven-Up Bottling Company Limited in its entirety for lacking in merit.

The court presided over by Hon. Justice Sinmisola Adeniyi held that Daniel’s has placed no credible evidence before the Court to establish that he indeed suffered disability at the material time, and also failed to establish conclusively any act of the breach of duty of care.

From facts, the claimant’s – Mr. Shedrach Daniel had submitted that in 2015, while in the employment of the firm he had an accident and sustained injuries that he was rushed to a private hospital for the treatment which he settled the medical bill personally and alleged further that due to the injury sustained from the accident he lost the use of his right hand and amenities of life, sought for the sum of N3,000,000.00 (Three Million Naira) for the trauma, loss of amenities and permanent disability suffered.

The Claimant alleged that his appointment was subsequently terminated by the firm for being redundant due to the loss of his right hand.

In defence, the firm contended that there was no formal report by the Claimant of the accident and/or injury sustained and that the said accident and/or injury did not occur in the official duties that the Claimant had the duty to officially report the accident that the Claimant ought to have obtained medical treatment at the hospital retained by the company.

Ogrih: Court Adjourns Case Against 2 Delta Journalists Over ‘Unpreparedness’ Of Claimant

Advertisement
Article Banner

The firm counsel Valentin Ajibo Esq asked for determination whether from the totality of evidence led and the circumstances of the case if the Claimant has proved his case and is entitled to the relief sought.

Delivering the Judgment, the presiding Judge, Hon. Justice Adeniyi held that Daniel’s failed to categorically or precisely state how the firm breached the duty of care or the manner in which the conduct of the firm was careless which consequently occasioned the damage or loss suffered by him.

“My finding in this regard is therefore that the Claimant failed to establish the material point, by cogent evidence, as to the particular manner and circumstances by which the Defendant purportedly breached the duty of care, other than merely stating that he had an accident and was treated in a hospital.

“I have examined the said Medical Report, Even though the Claimant claimed he was incapacitated by the accident, there is nothing in the document that states as such. The undated document is a mere result of an examination purportedly conducted on the Claimant and the treatment administered on him.

“On a final note, therefore, my conclusion and judgment is that the Claimant’s case, in its entirety, is feeble, lacked in merit and substance. It shall be and it is hereby accordingly dismissed.”

Advertisement
Article Banner
FOLLOW BIGPEN NIGERIA - Get Breaking News Alerts
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment
FEATURED2 hours ago

‘I Feel Your Pain Too’: Tinubu Recalls Water Cut While Shaving At Villa, Vows To Fix Power, Water

FEATURED6 hours ago

How Drug Cartel Used Golfer, Kenyan Chef to Smuggle 50kg Cannabis Into Nigeria

FEATURED18 hours ago

2027: Akpabio Warns Politicians Against Do-Or-Die Elections

bolt driver
FEATURED18 hours ago

Reps Consider Divorce Over 3 Months Without Sex, Emotional Abuse

Elections
FEATURED18 hours ago

Tinubu Promises Better Electricity, Leyland Factory Revival in Ibadan

Ransom
Defense and Security1 day ago

Kidnap Inc: How Informants, Crypto Launderers And Bandits Run Nigeria’s N7.78 Billion Ransom Business

FEATURED1 day ago

‘They Went To Bury The Dead, They Became The Dead’ — Oborevwori Mourns Bayelsa Boat Victims

FEATURED1 day ago

Edo Has 2.8 Million Registered Voters, Says REC

FEATURED1 day ago

Tinubu Orders Low-Key APC Rally in Ibadan Over Bayelsa Boat Tragedy

FEATURED2 days ago

Obi to Tinubu: You’re Tired, Go and Rest – Says Presidency Requires Energy

FEATURED2 days ago

Funeral Boat Capsizes In Bayelsa, 4 Dead Including 2 Children, Others Missing

Segun Odegbami
#SPORTS2 days ago

How 74-Year-Old Odegbami Fought Back, Chased Away 3 Armed Men Who Broke Into His Abeokuta Home

FEATURED2 days ago

‘Your Own Witnesses Said My Name Is Not There’ — Yahaya Bello Dares EFCC Over N190.6bn Cases, Says I Will Be Vindicated

FEATURED2 days ago

Seplat CEO Effiong Okon: No AI Without Energy, No Energy Without AI

FEATURED2 days ago

Court Rejects Atiku’s Fresh Evidence in Suit Against Tinubu Over NYSC Certificate

Advertisement
Advertisement

z

   


Article Banner